In early 2001, Carl Newman had the kind of run most musicians dream about. The New Pornographers' Mass Romantic made the New York Times' list of the year's best records nobody heard, drew raves in Rolling Stone and Spin, and won a Juno. At South by Southwest, Ray Davies joined the band onstage for "Starstruck." Then a transit strike hit, and Newman walked miles home in the rain from a job he hated, wondering what more he had to do.
That gap between acclaim and a paycheck runs through his bonus interview for 2004: The Year Indie Rock Broke, and it started closing with a label. Matador was Newman's dream, and record stores helped it find him. Aquarius Records in San Francisco championed Mass Romantic early, and Other Music pushed it in New York. The internet helped in a messier way. Mint's distribution was so thin that one fan at a Brooklyn show told Newman he'd searched eight stores before grabbing the album off Limewire, though he still bought a ticket and a T-shirt. Back home, a FACTOR grant paid for Newman's solo record, and arts funding let a wave of Canadian bands tour the world.
Once the records were in the bins, the numbers started to climb, and then the definition of success kept moving. Electric Version sold about 5,500 copies in its first week in 2003, and Matador was thrilled. Twin Cinema did 19,200 in 2005, more than Sub Pop had ever sold in a single week. Then The Shins' next album opened around 120,000, Arcade Fire's second did six figures, and when Challengers did roughly 21,000, the label called it disappointing. Newman remembers Ben Gibbard fretting backstage that a Death Cab for Cutie show had sold only 6,000 tickets. To Newman, that number would have meant being the biggest band in the world.
What kept him afloat through those shifts was licensing, which carried him for about eight years. "The Bleeding Heart Show" soundtracked a University of Phoenix ad, and a solo song went to Target. Raised in a working-class home, he saw little reason to refuse $20,000. Some deals paid off in ways he never expected, like the Rock Band placement for "Electric Version."
What he didn't see coming was streaming, or a public that bristles at being asked to pay for music at all. Fans getting back at labels for the old CD markups, he argues, mostly end up hurting artists instead. As music went free, the biggest acts kept growing while everyone else fought for their place. Two decades on, Newman admits to daydreaming about a job at the post office, somewhere his worth isn't tied to a radio single. Even so, he knows how lucky The New Pornographers were to be there for the gold rush.
The full interview below is for subscribers only.